All-State
Players
| Photo | Name/Position | Year | Coach | Highlights |
 |
Jim Gregory Pitcher |
1976 | Robert Hodgdon | 1st All-State baseball player at OTHS. Held several OTHS pitching records and still holds the innings pitched record for a season with 96.3. He is currently 2nd in Wins with 13, Jim went 13-1 in 1976. |
 |
Mike Harrawood Pitcher |
1983 | Robert Hodgdon | |
 |
Pat Hoey 1st Base |
1983 | Robert Hodgdon | |
 |
Rob Reidelberger Pitcher |
1994 | Art Voellinger | Rob was named IHSA Pitcher of the Year in 1994 as he led the area in ERA and helped lead his team to the state tournament. |
 |
Don O'Keefe Pitcher |
1994 | Art Voellinger | Don was a 3 year starter for the Panthers and helped team up with a pitching rotation that led the area in just about every category, the team reached the state tournament. |
 |
Mike Bowen Pitcher/Outfield |
1996 1997 1998 |
Art Voellinger | Mike is the first player in OTHS history to repeat as an All-State player, not once, but twice. The 3-time All-Stater still holds many OTHS records in both hitting and pitching, including a career record 24 HR's. |
 |
Brooks Colvin Shortstop |
2000 | Art Voellinger | Brooks was an All-State player in 2000 and still ranks among the all-time great Panther players in just about every offensive category. He later went on to Southwest Missouri State University (now Missouri State) where his team reached the College World Series. Brooks was drafted by the Detroit Tigers after his years with SMS. |
 |
Kellen Kettwich Centerfield |
2003 | Jason Portz | Kellen ended his stellar Panther career with an All-State award and he still ranks among the all-time leaders in just about every offensive category. He still holds the Most Singles record. |
 |
John Campbell 2nd Base |
2003 | Jason Portz | John joined his teamate Kellen Kettwich as an All-State player in 2003. He ranks among the Panther leaders in Singles and Stolen Bases as he swiped 22 bags in 2003. |
 |
Matt Wicinski 2nd Base |
2004 | Jason Portz | Wicinski made the transition from 3B to 2B just fine as he notched All-State Honors. He still ranks among many of the offensive leaders in Panther history. |