| Name | Year | Coach | College | | | Conference/Accomplishments |
| Bradley Harrison | 2016 | Portz | Southern Illinois University Cdale | NCAA | D-I | MVC |
| Camden Bauer | 2016 | Portz | University of Alabama | NCAA | D-I | SEC |
| Dillon Weiss | 2016 | Portz | Truman State University | NCAA | D-II | GLVC |
| Chris Holba | 2015 | Portz | East Carolina University | NCAA | D-I | American Atlantic (2016 NCAA Super-Regionals) |
| Jackson Penrod | 2015 | Portz | Fontbonne University | NCAA | D-III | |
| Nick Crabtree | 2015 | Portz | SWIC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Blake Deatherage | 2014 | Portz | McKendree University/Rend Lake CC | NCAA | D-II | GLVC |
| Collin Holton | 2014 | Portz | SWIC/McKendree University | NCAA | D-II | GLVC |
| Dean Gerros | 2014 | Portz | SWIC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Dillon Ritter | 2014 | Portz | Lincoln College/mORTHLAND | NAIA | JUCO | |
| Jeffery Hahs | 2014 | Portz | John A. Logan/Cambell University | NCAA | D-I | Big South |
| Brenndon Tindall | 2013 | Portz | Kansas City Community College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Ethan Wild | 2013 | Portz | Oakton Community College | NAIA | JUCO | Skyway Conference |
| Tanner Hudson | 2013 | Portz | Heartland CC/UMSL | NCAA | D-II | GLVC |
| Kyle Wilson | 2012 | Portz | SWIC/UMSL | NCAA | D-II | GLVC |
| Sam Hopkins | 2012 | Portz | SIUE | NCAA | D-I | OVC |
| Austin Bossart | 2011 | Portz | Penn | NCAA | D-I | Ivy League (2015 Ivy Player of Year, 2014-15 Team MVP)/Drafted by Phillies |
| Cody Seeberger | 2011 | Portz | Olney CC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Justin Busekrus | 2011 | Portz | Rend Lake CC/UMSL | NCAA | D-II | GLVC |
| Justin Wallace | 2011 | Portz | Fontbonne University | NCAA | D-III | |
| Matt Meadows | 2011 | Portz | Austin Peay State University | NCAA | D-I | OVC |
| Sam Summerlin | 2011 | Portz | Cedarville University | NCAA | D-II | |
| Miles Quintall | 2010 | Portz | Lincoln College/SWIC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Robert Berger | 2010 | Portz | Fontbonne University | NCAA | D-III | |
| Seth Wild | 2010 | Portz | Mineral Area College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Jon Levin | 2009 | Portz | SLU/River City Rascals | NCAA | D-I | Atlantic 10/Career record in pitching appearances |
| Keith Wolf | 2009 | Portz | St. Louis CC/SWIC/Coker College | NCAA | D-II | 2013 D-II National Championship Finalists |
| Kyle Stanton | 2009 | Portz | SWIC/Illinois State University | NCAA | D-I | Conference POY SWIC/1st Team All-MVC ISU |
| Max Goewert | 2009 | Portz | Lewis and Clark CC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Nick Johnson | 2009 | Portz | SIU-C | NCAA | D-I | MVC |
| Nick Tindall | 2009 | Portz | Drafted By Twins/Quincy/Tampa U | NCAA | D-II | 2015 DII National Champions/2016 Runner-ups |
| Brandon Gass | 2008 | Portz | St. Louis CC/SWIC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Brian Boeving | 2008 | Portz | Illinois College | NCAA | D-III | |
| Caleb Piatt | 2008 | Portz | St. Charles CC/Dallas Baptist University | NCAA | D-I | MVC (NCAA Super-Regionals) |
| Chris Hewitt | 2008 | Portz | Lewis and Clark CC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Dakota Curlee | 2008 | Portz | Kaskaskia College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| DJ Urscheler | 2008 | Portz | Aurora University | NCAA | D-III | |
| John Pilackas | 2008 | Portz | SWIC/UMSL | NCAA | D-II | GLVC |
| Brandon Heard | 2007 | Portz | Rend Lake CC/UAB | NCAA | D-I | Conference USA |
| Jeremy Pope | 2007 | Portz | Rockhurst University | NCAA | D-II | |
| Jesse Schmidt | 2007 | Portz | Rend Lake CC/Lindenwood University | NAIA | | |
| Brian Gass | 2006 | Portz | Indiana State University/SWIC | NCAA | D-I | MVC |
| Jordan Colvin | 2006 | Portz | Indiana State/SWIC/Eastern KY/Bradley | NCAA | D-I | MVC/OVC/MVC |
| LJ Watson | 2006 | Portz | SLU/Williams Wood University | NCAA | D-I | Atlantic 10 |
| Mark Daniels | 2006 | Portz | McKendree College | NAIA | | |
| Matt Goldschmidt | 2006 | Portz | Wililam Jewel | NAIA | | |
| Tyler Harris | 2006 | Portz | Indiana State/SIUE | NCAA | D-I | MVC/OVC |
| Chris Gottschall | 2005 | Portz | Kaskaskia College/IUPU Fort Wayne | NCAA | D-I | Summit League |
| Daniel Gebert | 2005 | Portz | Christian Brothers University | NCAA | D-II | Gulf South Conference |
| Mark Loehr | 2005 | Portz | Fontbonne University | NCAA | D-III | |
| Chris Streiber | 2004 | Portz | Mid America Nazareen | NCAA | D-III | |
| Danny Kruep | 2004 | Portz | Southern Illinois University Eville | NCAA | D-II | |
| Jon Gooding | 2004 | Portz | John Wood Community College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Matt Wicinski | 2004 | Portz | SWIC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Jason Cobb | 2003 | Portz | Eastern Illinois University | NCAA | D-I | OVC |
| John Campbell | 2003 | Portz | Knox College | NCAA | D-III | |
| John Piatt | 2003 | Portz | Kaskaskia College/William Woods | NAIA | | |
| Justin Hutto | 2003 | Portz | Union College | NAIA | | |
| Kellen Kettwich | 2003 | Portz | McKendree College | NAIA | | |
| Ryan Meyler | 2003 | Portz | McKendree College | NAIA | | |
| Will Lawrence | 2003 | Portz | St. Charles Community College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Derek Stratman | 2001 | Voellinger | SWIC/Missouri State/SIUE | NCAA | D-I | |
| Brooks Colvin | 2000 | Voellinger | Missouri State | NCAA | D-I | MVC (Reached CWS)/Drafted by Detroit Tigers |
| Mike Bowen | 1999 | Voellinger | Missouri State | NCAA | D-I | MVC |
| Jon Weaving | 1995 | Voellinger | McKendree University | NAIA | | |
| Brian Funk | 1994 | Voellinger | Bradley University/University of Illinois | NCAA | D-I | MVC/Big Ten (1998 Big 10 Champs/NCAA Tourney) |
| Don O Keefe | 1994 | Voellinger | McKendree College | NAIA | | |
| Chris McCollum | 1992 | Fink/Voellinger | SWIC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Jason Portz | 1992 | Voellinger | Kaskaskia College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Charles Tolbert | 1991 | Fink/Voellinger | SWIC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Eric Albrecht | 1991 | Fink/Voellinger | Quincy College | NAIA | | |
| Todd Wilkins | 1991 | Fink/Voellinger | Rend Lake CC | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Tom Ahle | 1991 | Fink/Voellinger | Kaskaskia College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Walter Owens | 1991 | Fink/Voellinger | Odessa College/Univeristy of Miami | NCAA | D-I | Big East (1994 CWS)/Drafted by Cleveland Indians |
| James Meade | 1990 | Fink | McKendree College | NAIA | | |
| Kit Zimmerman | 1990 | Fink | McKendree College | NAIA | | |
| Brian Garrett | 1989 | Fink | Odessa College/Florida International | NCAA | D-I | Drafted by Cleveland Indians |
| Tom George | 1988 | Fink | Florida Institute of Technology | NCAA | D-II | Sunshine State Conference |
| Jim Gregory | 1976 | Henson/Hodgen | Eastern Illinois University | NCAA | D-I | |
| Paul Buschmann | 1975 | Galen Henson | Middle Georgia College | NCAA | JUCO | |
| Paul Buschmann | 1975 | Galen Henson | Mercer University | NCAA | D-I | TAC Conference Champions 1978 |
| Craig Votrian | 1970 | Holmes/Henson | Belleville Area College/McKendree College | NAIA | | MVP McKendree 1974 |