State Tournament Teams
| Team Photo | Year | Coach | Players | Highlights |
|
|
1974 Panthers Team Photo Missing |
Robert Hodgdon | Coming Soon | 1st baseball team to reach the state tournament. State Semi-Finalists. |
 |
1976 Panthers | Robert Hodgdon | Coming Soon | 2nd team in 3 years to reach the state tournament. State Semi-Finalists. |
 |
1994 Panthers | Art Voellinger | Coming Soon | 1994 team ends 18 year drought of missing the state tournament. State Quarter-Finalists. |
 |
2006 Panthers | Jason Portz | Coming Soon | 2006 team ends 12 year drought of missing the state tournament. Team finishes 3rd in the state giving OTHS its first ever state tournament trophy. |
 |
2009 Panthers | Jason Portz | Coming Soon | 2009 team is the 2nd team in 4 years to place 3rd in the IHSA State Tournament. IHSA expanded to a 4 class system and it's the first Class 4A trophy for OTHS. |